62

May 15, 2023
Inside Aaron Judge's record-breaking 2022 season. On Oct. 4, 2022, the Yankees outfielder smashed his 62nd regular-season home run, breaking the American League record set in 1961 by another Yankees great, Roger Maris. Sluggers Sammy Sosa, Mark McGwire, and Barry Bonds broke Maris' record decades ago, but as various observers note in this book--including Maris' son, who contributes a foreword--those were steroid-era achievements, and Judge likely stands alone as the "clean home run king." However you cut the numbers, Judge had a remarkable season, and Hoch, a Yankees beat reporter for Major League Baseball, had excellent access to the triumphs and grind of the season. Speeding through Judge's backstory--adopted, mixed-race, very tall, and prodigiously talented--the author offers a clout-by-clout rundown of every homer, but he works some interesting side stories into the main narrative. The question of whether Judge would sign a new deal with the Yankees loomed over the season, and his efforts to serve as a team leader intensified as the season dragged on. The team suffered a serious second-half slump, and divisive teammate Josh Donaldson fielded accusations of racism after an on-field confrontation with the White Sox's Tim Anderson. Interspersed with Judge's story are flashbacks to Maris' 1961 record-setting run, which entailed a lot of understandable stress and (less understandably for an athlete) cigarettes. Hoch can be fussy on pitch-by-pitch approaches and other minutiae (what did the Yankees offer fans in exchange for those home-run balls?), and the ending is anticlimactic: The Yankees fell short in the playoffs, during which a gassed Judge hit an anemic .139. Still, the book holds interest as a tale of leadership claimed and tested; Judge's earning the rare title of Yankees team captain the following season, it's clear, was no small feat. Solid baseball reporting, rich with both stats geekery and human-interest stories.

COPYRIGHT(2023) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

May 29, 2023
Hoch (The Bronx Zoom), a reporter for MLB.com, provides a listless account of Aaron Judge’s historic 2022 season with the New York Yankees, during which he hit 62 home runs, setting the American League record for the most in a single season. Hoch details the circumstances of each home run and the team’s vicissitudes as it unsuccessfully pursued another World Series title. Largely glossing over Judge’s life pre-Yankees, Hoch details how the team got out to a strong start in 2022, with Judge on a hot streak that inspired speculation he could break Roger Maris’s 1961 home run record. However, the team’s prospects faded as they entered a mid-season slump and made an ill-fated trade for pitcher Frankie Montas, whose shoulder injury turned out to be more severe than the Yankees realized. Nonetheless, Judge’s streak continued, and in the penultimate game of the regular season against the Texas Rangers he hit his record-breaking 62nd home run. Hoch’s matter-of-fact storytelling and labored prose struggle to capture the excitement of the story, and sections about the hostility Maris encountered from fans who didn’t want him to surpass Babe Ruth’s record feel like filler. Dry and underwhelming, this doesn’t connect.